Butter vs. No Butter: A Tarte Tatin Taste Test 🍎
At first glance, it looks like a simple apple tart—but this is a homemade Tarte Tatin, the classic French upside-down caramelized apple dessert.
To make things more interesting, I baked two versions: one with butter, and one without.
The Butter Version
- Rich, full flavor
- Easier to slice and serve
- Smooth, indulgent texture
The No-Butter Version
- Apples keep their shape
- Brighter acidity
- Rustic, chunky bite
Personally, I preferred the butter version—it had a mellow richness and was easier to handle.
The no-butter version, cooked quickly over medium heat, kept the apple pieces intact but released a little extra liquid.
Next time, I might simmer it more gently to reduce that.
In short:
- If you enjoy bold apple flavor and a rustic bite, go for no butter.
- If you prefer a silky, mellow texture, butter is the way to go.
Tea Pairing: Janat Earl Grey
After baking, I sliced into the tart and enjoyed it with tea.
While I love brewing loose leaves in a teapot, I often reach for tea bags for everyday convenience.
One of my favorites is Janat, a French tea brand that’s easy to find at local shops.
Their individually wrapped bags keep the fragrance fresh, which I appreciate.
Today’s choice was Janat Black Series Earl Grey, blended with bergamot oil—a recipe unchanged since 1923.
The citrus notes balanced the tartness of the apples beautifully.
I also think their Caramel tea (from the Provence series) would pair wonderfully with Tarte Tatin.
The caramel flavor would echo the caramelized apples, creating a sweet harmony.
Sadly, I’ve already finished my stash, but I’ll try that pairing next time.
Join the Taste Test
So, what would you choose:
- The buttery, mellow Tarte Tatin
- Or the rustic, no-butter version
And which tea would you pair it with—classic Earl Grey or indulgent Caramel?
👉 For the preparation details, see my earlier post:🍎 Tarte Tatin with Fuji Apples — Preparation Stage
最近のコメント